4948 2005-09-12 01:41:57 -0700 Incorrect HTML entity error recovery doesn't match other browsers 2014-11-10 12:52:08 -0800 1 1 1 Unclassified WebKit DOM 420+ Mac OS X 10.4 RESOLVED FIXED HasReduction, InRadar P3 Enhancement --- 6446 32377 1 ap webkit-unassigned abarth darin ddkilzer ian mike oldest_to_newest 19448 0 ap 2005-09-12 01:41:57 -0700 (from discussion in bug 4820) Attached is a test matrix for invalid HTML entities with results for several browsers. Apparently, different browsers have little in common here, yet Safari matches none of them. Perhaps, this should be improved. 19449 1 3875 ap 2005-09-12 01:42:23 -0700 Created attachment 3875 test matrix 26957 2 eric 2005-12-28 01:35:59 -0800 What a great table. The code for all this is inside htmltokenizer.cpp. 75604 3 ap 2008-03-28 02:17:32 -0700 Bug 17689 has an example of this. 75605 4 ap 2008-03-28 02:17:57 -0700 <rdar://problem/5827553> 87237 5 sam 2008-07-28 17:52:38 -0700 This logic should be covered by http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/tokenization.html#consume 303218 6 abarth 2010-11-01 22:21:53 -0700 Our goal here is to match the HTML5 spec. How does a WebKit nightly compare to Firefox 4 beta? 303219 7 abarth 2010-11-01 22:24:18 -0700 Looks like we match Firefox 4 on everything except: &#4294967393; &#18446744073709551713; &#79228162514264337593543950433; &#x100000061; 1047602 8 ddkilzer 2014-11-10 12:52:08 -0800 (In reply to comment #7) > Looks like we match Firefox 4 on everything except: > > &#4294967393; > &#18446744073709551713; > &#79228162514264337593543950433; > &#x100000061; The above test cases match "Firefox (Mac)" column, and WebKit matches Firefox 33.1 except for these four cases (which look like regressions in Firefox per the chart): &#4294967393; (0x100000061) &#18446744073709551713; &#79228162514264337593543950433; &#x100000061; Marking as RESOLVED/FIXED. 3875 2005-09-12 01:42:23 -0700 2005-09-12 01:42:23 -0700 test matrix bad-entities.html text/html 3622 ap PEhFQUQ+Cjx0aXRsZT5IVE1MIGVudGl0aWVzIGVycm9yIHJlY292ZXJ5PC90aXRsZT4KPG1ldGEg aHR0cC1lcXVpdj0iQ29udGVudC1UeXBlIiBjb250ZW50PSJ0ZXh0L2h0bWw7IGNoYXJzZXQ9dXRm LTgiPgo8L0hFQUQ+CjxCT0RZPgo8dGFibGU+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRkPjwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPldpbklF PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+TWFjSUU8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5GaXJlZm94IChNYWMpPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+T3Bl cmEgKE1hYyk8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5DdXJyZW50PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7 Izk3OyAoZ29vZCk8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmE8L3RkPgog CTx0ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+JiM5Nzs8L3RkPgogPC90cj4KIDx0cj4KIAk8dGQ+JmFtcDsjMDAw MDAwMDk3OzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPj88L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRk PmE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mIzAwMDAwMDA5Nzs8L3RkPgogPC90cj4KIDx0cj4KIAk8dGQ+JmFtcDsj MDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDA5Nzs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4/PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRk PmE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+JiMwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDk3OzwvdGQ+CiA8 L3RyPgogPHRyPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wOyMyNjg0MzU1NTM7ICgweDEwMDAwMDYxKTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRk Pj88L3RkPgogCTx0ZD48L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5icm9rZW48L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5icm9rZW48L3RkPgog CTx0ZD4mIzI2ODQzNTU1Mzs8L3RkPgogPC90cj4KIDx0cj4KIAk8dGQ+JmFtcDsjNTM2ODcxMDA5 OyAoMHgyMDAwMDA2MSk8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4/PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YnJva2Vu PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YnJva2VuPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+JiM1MzY4NzEwMDk7PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8 dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7IzQyOTQ5NjczOTM7ICgweDEwMDAwMDA2MSk8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4/PC90 ZD4KIAk8dGQ+PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mIzQyOTQ5Njcz OTM7PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7IzE4NDQ2NzQ0MDczNzA5NTUxNzEzOzwv dGQ+CiAJPHRkPj88L3RkPgogCTx0ZD48L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJ PHRkPiYjMTg0NDY3NDQwNzM3MDk1NTE3MTM7PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7 Izc5MjI4MTYyNTE0MjY0MzM3NTkzNTQzOTUwNDMzOzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPj88L3RkPgogCTx0ZD48 L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPiYjNzkyMjgxNjI1MTQyNjQzMzc1 OTM1NDM5NTA0MzM7PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7I3g2MTsgKGdvb2QpPC90 ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJ PHRkPiYjeDYxOzwvdGQ+CiA8L3RyPgogPHRyPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wOyN4MDAwMDAwMDYxOzwvdGQ+ CiAJPHRkPj88L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmE8L3RkPgogCTx0 ZD4mI3gwMDAwMDAwNjE7PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7I3gwMDAwMDAwMDAw MDAwMDA2MTs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4/PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmE8L3RkPgogCTx0 ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+JiN4MDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAwNjE7PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJ PHRkPiZhbXA7I3gxMDAwMDA2MTs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4/PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+ YnJva2VuPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YnJva2VuPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+JiN4MTAwMDAwNjE7PC90ZD4KIDwv dHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7I3gyMDAwMDA2MTs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4/PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+ PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YnJva2VuPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YnJva2VuPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+JiN4MjAwMDAw NjE7PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7I3gxMDAwMDAwNjE7PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+ PzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPjwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+JiN4MTAw MDAwMDYxOzwvdGQ+CiA8L3RyPgogPHRyPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wOyN4NjEtMDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4m YW1wOyN4NjEtMDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hLTA7PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YS0wOzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmEt MDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mI3g2MS0wOzwvdGQ+CiA8L3RyPgogPHRyPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wOyN4NjFH MDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wOyN4NjFHMDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hRzA7PC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YUcw OzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmFHMDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mI3g2MUcwOzwvdGQ+CiA8L3RyPgogPHRyPgog CTx0ZD4mYW1wOyM5N0YwOzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmFGMDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5hRjA7PC90ZD4KIAk8 dGQ+YUYwOzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPmFGMDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mIzk3RjA7PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8 dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7ZWFjdXRlJmx0O2EvPjE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD7DqTE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD7D qTE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD7DqTE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD7DqTE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mZWFjdXRlPGEvPjE8 L3RkPgogPC90cj4KIDx0cj4KIAk8dGQ+JmFtcDtlYWN1dGUrMTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPsOpKzE8L3Rk PgogCTx0ZD7DqSsxPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+w6krMTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPsOpKzE8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4m ZWFjdXRlKzE8L3RkPgogPC90cj4KIDx0cj4KIAk8dGQ+JmFtcDtlYWN1dGUmYW1wO2VhY3V0ZTs8 L3RkPgogCTx0ZD7DqcOpPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+w6nDqTwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPsOpw6k8L3RkPgogCTx0 ZD7DqcOpPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+JmVhY3V0ZSZlYWN1dGU7PC90ZD4KIDwvdHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRk PiZhbXA7ZWFjdXQmYW1wO2VhY3V0ZTs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wO2VhY3V0w6k8L3RkPgogCTx0 ZD4mYW1wO2VhY3V0w6k8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wO2VhY3V0w6k8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wO2Vh Y3V0w6k8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mZWFjdXQmZWFjdXRlOzwvdGQ+CiA8L3RyPgogPHRyPgogCTx0ZD4m YW1wO2VhY3V0ZWVhY3V0ZTs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD7DqWVhY3V0ZTs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD7DqWVhY3V0 ZTs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wO2VhY3V0ZWVhY3V0ZTs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mYW1wO2VhY3V0ZWVh Y3V0ZTs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mZWFjdXRlZWFjdXRlOzwvdGQ+CiA8L3RyPgogPHRyPgogCTx0ZD4m YW1wO2VhY3V0OzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPiZlYWN1dDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mZWFjdXQ7PC90ZD4KIAk8 dGQ+JmVhY3V0OzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPiZlYWN1dDs8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4mZWFjdXQ7PC90ZD4KIDwv dHI+CiA8dHI+CiAJPHRkPiZhbXA7IzExOTU5OTsgKGdvb2QpPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YnJva2VuPC90 ZD4KIAk8dGQ+PzwvdGQ+CiAJPHRkPvCdjK88L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5icm9rZW48L3RkPgogCTx0ZD4m IzExOTU5OTs8L3RkPgogPC90cj4KIDx0cj4KIAk8dGQ+JmFtcDsjNTUzNDg7JmFtcDsjNTcxMzU7 IChzdXJyb2dhdGUgcGFpcik8L3RkPgogCTx0ZD5icm9rZW48L3RkPgogCTx0ZD48L3RkPgogCTx0 ZD7wnYyvPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+YnJva2VuPC90ZD4KIAk8dGQ+JiM1NTM0ODsmIzU3MTM1OzwvdGQ+ CiA8L3RyPgo8L3RkPgo8L3RhYmxlPgo8L0JPRFk+Cg==